Pope Francis has shaped the next conclave, but his successor could not continue his legacy

These 12 years of pontificate, however, have found him in a bed of the Gemelli Hospital in Rome, hospitalized since February 14 for pneumonia. Although in recent days, the 88 -year -old Pope has presented a slight improvement, his condition is still delicate, so for weeks he has been speculating about what would happen if the end of his mandate arrives.

The Cardenalicio College is the body in charge of choosing the pontiffs and on it they have put their eyes, since their current composition could give an idea of ​​how the chips will move in case of a conclave.

It is not exaggerated to say that Francisco has shaped the Cardinal College, since he has chosen 80% of the cardinals, which also come from 71 countries from almost every corner of the world, removing weight to the traditional European squares to focus more on Africa and Asia, where Catholicism comes up.

But the fact that Francisco has chosen most of the sloping ones who will choose his successor does not mean that the next Pope will be someone tailored. Due to geographical diversity, many of the cardinals are not known, which increases uncertainty and makes the result unpredictable, since we already know that many negotiations are handled in the vatican’s halls, and alliances and affinities are usually key to reaching agreements and increase or reduce support to certain “papable” candidates.

A reformist Pope

After the resignation of Benedict XVI, who felt that he had too many obstacles to be able to clean the image of a church overwhelmed by the complaints of abuse and corruption, Francisco had to take the post to deal with all those earrings. Therefore, he insisted on making reforms and putting a personal seal to each of his gestures and appointments to be able to restructure the Vatican and the Government of the Church, printing a missionary spirit inspired by the Jesuit tradition and in the universality of the Church.

(Commerce)

To this added his deepest concerns, such as the environment and immigration, colliding with the political agenda of the most conservative sectors in Europe and the United States. “The Church has received from Pope Francis the awareness of being a truly global church, not only a Catholicism with European, western traction. It is a change of time, a church of the third millennium, and this creates many tensions,” Massimo Faggioli, professor of the Department of Theology and Religious Sciences of the Villanova University, in Philadelphia, tells “El País”.

Around the world

At the same time, the most progressive sectors claim that they have not made enough changes, such as the end of the celibacy of priests or that women can officiate masses. And others point out that he has governed in an authoritative and impulsive manner, relegating those who disallow him.

The ‘Papables’

There are several names that have been playing as possible successors to the throne of Pedro, or that will be very influential for their choice.

In the case of the most conservatives are Cardinals Raymond Burke (United States), Gerhard Müller (Germany) and Robert Sarah (Guinea), who have openly criticized the reforms of the Pontiff and his approach to the LGBT community, the divorced and the request that women have greater participation in the ecclesiastical hierarchy. None of them are probably chosen, but they can exert their influence to bring the direction of the conclave towards a deep change with respect to Francisco.

There are also other conservatives, less furibly, such as Hungarian Péter Erdo, archbishop of Budapest and Cardinal Czech Dominik Duka.

“The Pope has meant for many people a way of accessing Jesus extremely concrete and simple”

Mons. Carlos Castillo, Cardinal and Archbishop of Lima

On the side of those who are more consistent with Francisco’s line, there are Cardinal Filipino Luis Antonio Tagle – who tell him the ‘Francisco Asian’- and the Italian Matteo Zuppi. In the pools there is also the current Secretary of State, Pietro Parolin, who knows the woven and manage of the Vatican and is considered a mediator who can dialogue between one side and another of the crack.

During the town hall of last year, the Pope emphasized that the Cardinal College must resemble a “symphony orchestra”, where each member, from various cultural and geographical contexts, contributes to “the symphony” of the Church and its unity.

In the Wanderer Walking Blog, which specializes in themes of the Catholic Church, an analysis of the cardinals designated by Francisco is made and not all have the same opening line. In fact, among those of the most remote countries of Rome there are several moderate and others that incline more conservative positions, as well as others much more progressive or open to deeper reforms, so it is a very varied cardinal school geographically, but also ideologically.

Candles are lit at the statue of John Paul II outside the Gemelli University Hospital where Pope Francis is hospitalized with pneumonia, in Rome on March 04, 2025. Pope Francis was breathing without a mask on March 4, 2025 after suffering two bouts of acute respiratory failure, the Vatican said as the leader of the world’s Catholics spent his 19th day in hospital with pneumonia. (Photo by Alberto PIZZOLI / AFP)

/ Alberto Pizzoli

The cardinals designated by Francisco They will undoubtedly make their weight feel and want to preserve the legacy of the pontiff that raised them, but maybe they consider that it is not the time of more changes to calm the waters.

Of course, nothing is said, but Vatican intrigues – which always feed books and movies – will be order in one of the most unpredictable conclaves in recent history.

In 12 years of pontificate, perhaps a Pope was asked to resume credibility in a Catholic Church hit by corruption and allegations of abuse. For some, their reforms were too fast and structural, for others too slow and contradictory. Nobody will ever be satisfied. But what Francisco changed was the spirit of a church that needed to be more pastoral and open to dialogue.

INTERVIEW

“You could opt for a not so reformist Pope”

Dra. Veronique Lecaros

Head of the PUCP Department of Theology

  • In these years, the Pope has appointed a large number of cardinals from different parts of the world with the objective, according to his words, of “integrating the peripheries.” But, on the most political side, it is pointed out that the Cardinal College has shaped to influence its successor. Is it really so?

Pope Francis has broken the habit that there are cardinal squares; That is, previously the bishop of certain cities in one or two years was created Cardinal (which is the term used). For example, in France, in Paris the Archbishop is not a cardinal. In Lyon, which was also a cardinal headquarters, either. But Francisco has broken this, is part of his governance, to include the peripheries of the Church and include all the voices. So, this attitude is also reflected in the way of choosing the new cardinals, of including the peripheries so that all the voices of the world are, as representatives and carriers of other realities.

  • In Africa and Asia the number of Catholics have increased. Could this be reflected in a future conclave?

At some point that will surely happen. In the Future Conclave there will be, for example, a Cardinal of Mongolia. The fact is that these cardinals do not know each other as much among them as it used to be the custom, because they come just from the periphery and do not circulate so much in Rome.

  • There is talk of a church with great internal tensions and with an opposition to the Pope that is visible. Why have these divisions be marked during Francisco’s pontificate?

One of the reasons is that the world tends to be polarized, and the Church is also not an institution that is outside the social conflicts we are living. But extremisms have also grown, there are very conservative groups that in certain countries have had the wind in stern. These are small groups but, depending on countries, have some power. Keep in mind that countries have very different dynamics. Precisely, because of this boom in some countries and that is reflected in the Church, it could be possible that in this Cardinal College, which Francis has thought more diverse and towards the peripheries, there is no connection between all the cardinals. For the logic of alliances, it could be that the school opts for a more traditionalist and not as reformist or opening pontiff as Francisco. There is a saying in Rome: “Who enters Pope to the conclave, comes out cardinal.”

  • For the ultraconservative line of Europe and the United States, a Pope who is aligned would be convenient. Will they have enough strength to get the appointment of a very conservative Pope?

These bishops and cardinals who are talking against Francisco have, say, the wind in their favor by all these nationalist, Christian and conservative currents, which have different characteristics according to countries. But not necessarily the issues of an episcopal conference correspond to the conclave, because the cardinals have just been chosen in a different way, they are other dynamics. Then, in the Conclave we would have the vast majority of cardinals who have been chosen by Francisco, according to their opening line, but faithful to the ecclesial doctrine. I think there are factors that can impact. Like that of abuses, which is no longer talked about, but that remains latent and can constitute a time bomb for the church. Also the financial issue, in which the Pope has struggled for more transparency. These issues will weigh a lot because there is the credibility of the Church.

  • The Pope has always said that he could give up. But would I really do it?

I could do it if it is very weakened. The issue of health does not depend on him and it is not known what he will decide. We have spoken in a very political way of the Church, but there is also the component of the Holy Spirit that always surprises us, and from a Christian perspective, Pope Francis has the conviction of having a mission. Precisely, he longed for this jubilee year, under the motto “Pilgrims of Hope.” It was an important milestone for him, in a world that just tends to lose hope.

By Editor

One thought on “Pope Francis has shaped the next conclave, but his successor could not continue his legacy”

Leave a Reply