Novel adaptation “Identitti” in the cinema: The Indian professor is white, so what?

A “Mixed-Race Wonder Woman” has no superpowers. At best, she is more sensitive to the privileges of the white majority society. Nivedita (Amanda Babaei Vieira) has a Polish mother and an Indian father. “I spent half my life longing to be whiter than I am. The other half I longed to be darker.” Her cousin Priti (Saba Lou Khan) calls her “coconut,” brown on the outside and white on the inside.

The rescue from this dilemma is embodied by her star professor in the subject of Intercultural Studies. Saraswati (Stephanie Eidt) floats like a saint through the corridors of Düsseldorf University in her white robes and with a bindi on her forehead. In the first hour she sends all the white students home. “This is racism!” complains a student. Check your privilege! Question in the lecture hall: “Which of you feels addressed by the term ‘of color’?” The sentence opens Nivedita’s eyes.

The question provokes a strong physical reaction in her non-white fellow students: They stagger towards the exit, twitching and walking like zombies. The remaining students collectively fall into a steady, undulating rhythm, as if their bodies were being penetrated by an invisible force. They raise their fists in a combative manner. A choreography of awareness, staged by Constanza Macras.

The right sex is a political question

Saraswati is no ordinary academic. “Why is the goddess Kaali on top during sex?” she wants to know. “Because for her it’s not a private preference, but a political question,” answers Nivedita. “That’s the first thing you teach people you want to oppress,” explains the professor. “That they are not lovable people.” Nivedita is beaming all over her face.

Which only leaves the question to be clarified: Is it enough to “feel” like a person of color?

 

Recommended editorial content

Here you will find external content selected by our editors to enrich the article with additional information for you. Here you can display or hide the external content with one click.

I agree that the external content can be displayed to me. This means that personal data can be transmitted to third-party platforms. You can find more information about this in the data protection settings. You can find these at the bottom of our page in the footer, so you can manage or revoke your settings at any time.

 

The novel “Identitti” by Mithu Sanyal five years ago revolved around such questions of (self-)attribution and belonging, identity based on skin color and the social experiences experienced as a result, and the reversal of exclusion into empowerment. The author, who has an Indian father and a mother of Polish origin, reflected the social discourse in an overheated mix of first-person narrative, social media posts and pop culture bits from the introductory seminar.

At that time, a small culture war had just broken out because the emerging awareness that talking about diversity should lead to action had also reached the center of society. The debate was largely benevolent, although not entirely without contradictions. As always when privileges are questioned. The staff of every Netflix series now looks like the pedestrian zone of any medium-sized German city.

And yet Randa Chahoud’s film adaptation of “Identitti” is coming to cinemas under slightly different circumstances. The social achievements of the past few years are shaky, the term “remigration” has seeped into the political discourse – positively or ex negativo – and the focus on the Middle East conflict has made the difference between white and non-white Germans more visible again.

Skin color as a social attribution

In 2021, “Identitti” – that is the nom de guerre under which Nivedita blogs – was also a reaction to the curious case of the US cultural scientist Rachel Dolezal, who had pretended to be black for years. In academic circles, the revelation sparked a debate about social attribution and to what extent skin color, like gender, is a social and not a biological attribution.

Sanyal in no way mocked this outrage over Dolezal’s assault. But she had fun with the controversy and the sometimes self-righteous positions used to attack or defend the academic. As a person who has personally experienced the social attribution of skin color, she alternated between the roles of the angry student and – as the devil’s advocate – the white lecturer who felt black.

Best friends. Oluchi (Zoe Magdalena, from left), Nivedita (Amanda Babaei Vieira) and Priti (Saba Lou Khan).

© PR/Frank Dicks / Alamode Film

Saraswati is Rachel Dolezal. The professor recognizes Nivedita’s bright eyes as a docile student and makes her and her best friend Oluchi (Zoe Magdalena) her student assistants. Which also means watering the mentor’s flowers. In the apartment, Nivedita comes across an old photo, tanning cream and brown contact lenses. Saraswati’s actual name is Sarah Vera Thielmann, born in Karlsruhe.

And while Oluchi and Priti want to make their professor’s secret public, Nivedita, deeply disappointed by the fraud, wants to confront her mentor first. However, she sees nothing reprehensible in her imposture and argues with the theoretical tools of intercultural studies that skin color – in her case white – cannot be a fixed category of one’s own identity.

And isn’t she right? What about the political struggles in which one is supposed to resist the ascriptions of power? With Saraswati’s seductive words in her ears, Nivedita is confused. Oluchi and Priti, in turn, are planning a demonstration.

Sabrina Setlur als Göttin Kaali

Chahoud, who comes from a Syrian-German family, finds an original approach to Sanyal’s template. On the one hand, in the dance choreographies that are repeatedly interspersed, in which, similar to the St. Vitus dances in Ishmael Reed’s classic “Mumbo Jumbo”, the “obsession” with experiences of racism resonates. And in the appearance of ex-rapper Sabrina Setlur as the incarnation of the goddess Kaali, who occasionally nudges Nivedita in the right direction in her disorientation.

Rachel Dolezal is nothing more than a cultural footnote. But because attribution is now used more forcefully than ever to discredit “woker” identity politics, the questions that “Identitti” raises still seem to provoke. Because if you ignore the fact that even the supposedly free choice of skin color is ultimately a white privilege, in Saraswati’s “trans-ethnicity” appropriation and appreciation collapse in a twisted logic.

Nivedita describes Saraswati as an ally who leaves her guilt-ridden white body behind with lots of tanning cream – adopting her mentor’s perspective. It’s easy to make this argument easy and dismiss it as a justification strategy. Sanyal and Chahoud do not do this. And that’s why “Identitti” never seems like a manifesto, but more like a euphoric game with pop culture symbols.

 

By Editor

One thought on “Novel adaptation “Identitti” in the cinema: The Indian professor is white, so what?”
  1. XurshidKarimov's Profile – MyAnimeList.net
    Yusuprakhimov | 99Freelas
    Tarkastele profiilia käyttäjältä anon248734
    Post by @steadyjusticejungle
    UlugbekKadirov | ReverbNation
    Rqhsgj86Xd
    Newprofile
    1890892
    View the profile of UmidjonKhamdamov
    15027449847
    atabekismoilov | Mezink
    BobojonAliev
    51717392
    Dostonbekrakhmo
    GafurBabadjanov's Profile | The Cardinal Nation
    MobileSheets Forums – Profile of HusniddinGulyamov
    Jalolikromov
    Komilislamov
    MirjalolJalolov — Bio Sites
    View the profile of RustambekMukhammedov
    Samadniyozov
    MobileSheets Forums – Profile of ShavkatOdilov
    Shodiyorolimov
    Tarkastele profiilia käyttäjältä anon551655
    meyarow115's Profile
    Tariq Sadikov
    Tursunboysaidov
    51716610
    Tarkastele profiilia käyttäjältä anon307030
    %D0%98%D0%Bd%D1%82%D0%B5%D1%80%D0%B0%D0%Ba%D1%82%D0%B8%D0%B2%D0%Bd%D1%8B%D0%B9 %D0%Ba%D0%Bb%D1%83%D0%B1 Pin Up%3A %D1%80%D1%83%D0%Ba%D0%Be%D0%B2%D0%Be%D0%B4%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B2%D0%Be %D0%Bf%D0%Be %D1%81%D0%B5%D1%80%D1%82%D0%B8%D1%84%D0%B8%D1%86%D0%B8%D1%80%D0%Be%D0%B2%D0%B0%D0%Bd%D0%Bd%D1%8B%D0%Bc %D1%81%D0%Bb%D0%Be%D1%82%D0%B0%D0%Bc %D0%B2 %D0%A3%D0%B7%D0%B1%D0%B5%D0%Ba%D0%B8%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B0%D0%Bd%D0%B5 1399488907
    Post by @steadyjusticejungle
    Member Portal
    Азартная площадка Pin Up: оригинальные симуляторы в Узбекистане
    ParvizNazarov
    Firuz Qodirov
    SultonNematov's Profile | The Cardinal Nation
    Profile – DilshodGhafforov – Melanoma Research Foundation
    OzarMirzoev – Mining Doc
    ShohruhRustamov | Players list | Community | Bandori Party – BanG Dream! Girls Band Party
    Manuchehrmahmudov
    Rahmonvohidov
    About
    SadriddinSalimov – Watch Faces for Apple Watch, Apple Watch Ultra, Wear OS, Galaxy Watch, Pixel Watch, and more | Facer
    Pin Up Kyrgyzstan
    RuslanToktobaev's Profile – TruckyMods
    School Idol Tomodachi – DastanMamatov: Profile
    Almazmoldobaev
    eemilturgunov1
    @nadyrbaatyrov
    Newprofile

Leave a Reply